Repository navigation
refactor: extract Welcome migration presentation state - #232
Conversation
The design defines `ConfigMakerStatusPresentation<TSeverity>` as the focused owner of four status values and their ordered publication sequence. The owner receives three cold callback ports and preserves raw severity, nullable inline strings, equality behavior, and partial state after failures. The document keeps localization, notification construction, sender behavior, and the inline flag within the existing host adapters. The specified sequence resolves the title, raises the notice, reads the flag once, and conditionally updates four properties in order. The documented boundaries exclude unrelated partials, user controls, resources, workflows, platform surfaces, and release acceptance. The implementation plan separates portable characterization from native composition qualification. The plan records focused tests, a controlled ordering mutation, full managed checks, host guards, bounded native evidence, and independent reviews as pending work. The governance inventory registers both documents with their language policy, authorship metadata, and summarized scope. Changed files: - "docs/governance/document-inventory.json" (+20/-0 lines). - "docs/superpowers/plans/2026-11-11-configmaker-status-presentation.md" (+108/-0 lines). - "docs/superpowers/specs/2026-11-11-configmaker-status-presentation-design.md" (+127/-0 lines). The file counts compare the staged tree with its first parent. Refs: #228 Staged-Tree: c273657
The change moves four observable status values from ConfigMakerViewModel into ConfigMakerStatusPresentation<TSeverity>. The view model retains its public accessors and forwards property notifications from the new owner. The ShowEditorMessage method now delegates status publication through the typed presentation object. The presentation resolves the title, raises the current notice callback, and reads the inline setting once afterward. The presentation publishes title, message, severity, and open state in their existing order when inline display is enabled. The disabled path closes the current status without replacing the other values. The stored callbacks remain inactive during construction. The new tests characterize equality suppression, raw nullable values, callback ordering, nested calls, exception identity, partial updates, retries, and independent instances. The test project links the presentation source for direct coverage. The plan marks the completed managed implementation and build activities. The verification report records observed test, mutation, build, and contract results while identifying native and delivery qualification as pending. The governance inventory records the plan history and adds the verification report. Changed files: - "CDPIUI.Tests/CDPIUI.Tests.csproj" (+1/-0 lines). - "CDPIUI.Tests/Presentation/ConfigMakerStatusPresentationTests.cs" (+429/-0 lines). - "CDPIUI/ViewModels/ConfigMaker/ConfigMakerStatusPresentation.cs" (+68/-0 lines). - "CDPIUI/ViewModels/ConfigMaker/ConfigMakerViewModel.cs" (+22/-34 lines). - "docs/governance/document-inventory.json" (+13/-3 lines). - "docs/superpowers/plans/2026-11-11-configmaker-status-presentation.md" (+6/-6 lines). - "docs/superpowers/reports/2026-11-11-configmaker-status-presentation-verification.md" (+106/-0 lines). The file counts compare the staged tree with its first parent. Refs: #228 Staged-Tree: b7e14a2
The inventory records commit 05e0061 as the verification report's first introduction. The plan marks source review, fixture construction, exclusive leasing, and the single owned process run as complete. The report corrects the typed owner's physical size from 69 lines to 68 lines. The native qualification documents the immutable fixture, reconstructed inputs, preserved scenario data, independent reviews, and pinned artifact hashes. The build record reports zero warnings and errors, while the execution record reports 184 unique passing groups and no failures. The evidence also records one completed process, empty output streams, retained hash checks, and guarded lease release. The six new groups cover cold models, accessor behavior, severity text, notification state, nested effects, observer faults, retries, and instance independence. The report distinguishes normalized EventArgs values from nullable inline state and limits reflection to private member characterization. The stated boundaries exclude operating endpoints, desktop input, elevation, file operations, and unrelated workflows. The remaining section keeps delivery gates and unsupported native mutation cases pending. Changed files: - "docs/governance/document-inventory.json" (+2/-2 lines). - "docs/superpowers/plans/2026-11-11-configmaker-status-presentation.md" (+3/-3 lines). - "docs/superpowers/reports/2026-11-11-configmaker-status-presentation-verification.md" (+76/-8 lines). The file counts compare the staged tree with its first parent. Refs: #228 Staged-Tree: 3b92076
The verification report records a fresh independent review of the complete three-commit change range. The review found no Critical or Important findings and identified one Minor documentation inconsistency. The report attributes the review model, inspected evidence, reconstructed behavior, and execution boundaries. The corrected caller-null description now states that the native case proved an empty `EventArgs.Message` against a null inline `StatusMessage`. The inventory summary now includes accepted native184 composition, retained harness failures, and independent reviews. The summary keeps draft publication, CI, and local acceptance pending. The plan marks the whole-branch independent review task as complete. The report states that the reviewer executed no tests, builds, application, verification writer, or user interface. The report also preserves remaining runtime, visual, localization, operating, lifetime, ABI, integration, and release limits. The final verdict remains contingent on final-head CI, actual Project fields, and immediate local acceptance readback. Changed files: - "docs/governance/document-inventory.json" (+1/-1 lines). - "docs/superpowers/plans/2026-11-11-configmaker-status-presentation.md" (+1/-1 lines). - "docs/superpowers/reports/2026-11-11-configmaker-status-presentation-verification.md" (+22/-2 lines). The file counts compare the staged tree with its first parent. Refs: #228 Staged-Tree: 8ff3309
The design defines a typed owner for nine Welcome migration display values and two synchronous display policies. The owner preserves raw values, default equality behavior, notification order, reentry effects, and exception boundaries. The host retains eligibility, session, queue, import, lifecycle, and readiness responsibilities. The specification documents exact status and error lookup sequences, host forwarding, constructor composition, and explicit scope exclusions. The document attributes Project admission and the builder verdict to recorded evidence. The document also distinguishes portable owner checks from native host composition and broader integration qualification. The implementation plan divides the work into managed extraction and native composition stages. The first stage covers characterization, controlled mutation, source guards, managed tests, and the normal GUI build. The second stage defines six native composition groups while retaining the existing 184-case corpus. The plan keeps loaded wizard, operating migration, installed-product, integration, and release acceptance outside this stage. The governance inventory registers both documents with their language policy and ownership summary. Changed files: - "docs/governance/document-inventory.json" (+20/-0 lines). - "docs/superpowers/plans/2026-11-11-welcome-migration-presentation.md" (+141/-0 lines). - "docs/superpowers/specs/2026-11-11-welcome-migration-presentation-design.md" (+174/-0 lines). The file counts compare the staged tree with its first parent. Refs: #231 Staged-Tree: 8a89eae
The change moves nine migration display values into `WelcomeMigrationPresentation<TSeverity>`. The owner preserves defaults, equality suppression, raw nullable values, and derived ready-content visibility. The host retains private-set accessors and forwards owner notifications through its existing observable interface. The owner resolves status resources in assignment order and accepts explicit initial and error severities. The error policy selects nonblank localized text, appends the error code, and exposes retry visibility. The host keeps final Next-button disabling after the error policy returns. The tests characterize defaults, setter equality, numeric edge cases, notification order, nested updates, callback failures, partial state, and independent instances. The test project links the owner and display-item sources for direct coverage. The plan marks the managed implementation and verification tasks complete. The verification report records focused characterization, mutation results, full-suite results, build evidence, preservation checks, and pending native delivery gates. The governance inventory records the plan history and adds the verification report. Changed files: - "CDPIUI.Tests/CDPIUI.Tests.csproj" (+2/-0 lines). - "CDPIUI.Tests/Presentation/WelcomeMigrationPresentationTests.cs" (+430/-0 lines). - "CDPIUI/ViewModels/Welcome/WelcomeMigrationPresentation.cs" (+108/-0 lines). - "CDPIUI/ViewModels/Welcome/WelcomeViewModel.Migration.cs" (+22/-45 lines). - "CDPIUI/ViewModels/Welcome/WelcomeViewModel.cs" (+4/-0 lines). - "docs/governance/document-inventory.json" (+13/-3 lines). - "docs/superpowers/plans/2026-11-11-welcome-migration-presentation.md" (+7/-7 lines). - "docs/superpowers/reports/2026-11-11-welcome-migration-presentation-verification.md" (+136/-0 lines). The file counts compare the staged tree with its first parent. Refs: #231 Staged-Tree: 01874d9
The verification report records the product checkpoint and the technically compiled 190-group Welcome fixture. The report distinguishes inspected source scenarios from runtime evidence because no new native execution exists. The recorded build completed with zero warnings and errors, while source reconstruction, input pins, resources, executable metadata, and artifact hashes are documented. The six new groups cover composition, accessors, owner state, dispatch, localization, continuations, faults, retries, and observer effects. The report identifies derived-observer and missing-key behavior as unexecuted runtime conditions. The prepared view rejects operating endpoints, and cleanup affects only test observers and the owned framework cancellation source. The plan and design permit source review, an incomplete stacked draft, and hosted exact-head CI before native execution. The external user stop still blocks UI execution, native runs, and queue handoffs. The remaining gates include runtime review, Project field readback, local acceptance, and completed-state confirmation. The inventory now records the report introduction commit and summarizes the expanded evidence boundaries. Changed files: - "docs/governance/document-inventory.json" (+3/-3 lines). - "docs/superpowers/plans/2026-11-11-welcome-migration-presentation.md" (+8/-0 lines). - "docs/superpowers/reports/2026-11-11-welcome-migration-presentation-verification.md" (+45/-14 lines). - "docs/superpowers/specs/2026-11-11-welcome-migration-presentation-design.md" (+13/-1 lines). The file counts compare the staged tree with its first parent. Refs: #231 Staged-Tree: 9c4caa9
The plan records verified human authorization to resume the Welcome UI scope while preserving the earlier Esc stop and blocked packet. The plan keeps native execution dependent on fresh review, peer idle, and an exact new grant. The verification report distinguishes the Welcome, Project, and Lessons authorizations and states that their scopes are not interchangeable. The report documents the reviewed commit range, retained evidence, and the absence of native fixture execution or final acceptance. It attributes no product findings of Critical or Important severity to the independent source review. The report describes isolated failures in optimized Python checks and queue replacement behavior. The additive `native-operational-r2` packet rejects optimized execution and disables queue mutation entrypoints before state access. The report states that four regression groups cover optimized recipes, disabled mutations, competing ownership, and lease refusal. The report also documents Root-only grant and release serialization under a named mutex. Two deferred coverage observations remain for setter comparisons and cold-host event timing. Changed files: - "docs/superpowers/plans/2026-11-11-welcome-migration-presentation.md" (+8/-0 lines). - "docs/superpowers/reports/2026-11-11-welcome-migration-presentation-verification.md" (+52/-5 lines). The file counts compare the staged tree with its first parent. Staged-Tree: 0a82ed8
The plan marks source review, fixture preparation, exclusive native execution, and independent runtime review as complete. The plan keeps draft publication, delivery-head checks, Project completion, and local acceptance pending. The verification report records one bounded asInvoker run with 190 unique passing groups, zero failures, empty streams, and preserved earlier outputs. The report documents process absence, queue release, pinned inputs, retained-runtime evidence, and an independent review with no blocking findings. The report also records successful draft-head hosted checks and the observed PR Project metadata. The stated runtime boundary excludes loaded-window, visual, migration, cancellation, concurrency, installed-product, and other untested behavior. The design now distinguishes the historical UI stop from the later verified human resumption. The design describes corrected operational controls, sole Root coordination, fresh peer readiness, grant 173, and release 174. The documents attribute constructor coldness to inspected source because runtime observation began after observer subscription. The final delivery-head CI, completed Project readback, and case-specific local acceptance remain pending. Changed files: - "docs/superpowers/plans/2026-11-11-welcome-migration-presentation.md" (+5/-5 lines). - "docs/superpowers/reports/2026-11-11-welcome-migration-presentation-verification.md" (+53/-6 lines). - "docs/superpowers/specs/2026-11-11-welcome-migration-presentation-design.md" (+12/-1 lines). The file counts compare the staged tree with its first parent. Staged-Tree: 7f1ccd0
The report now identifies the technical checkpoint as a historical state rather than a current authorization. The checkpoint allowed source review, draft publication, and hosted CI before runtime under the documented external-stop amendment. The report states that native review, Project fields, and local acceptance were mandatory and incomplete at that time. The report now distinguishes the acceptance of Parents13, Parents14, Parents15, and earlier drafts as separate acceptance. The revised wording preserves the boundary that the report does not merge those records or declare Task2 complete. The resumption section now describes Root execution and verification status at that historical checkpoint. The report directs readers to later sections for the subsequent native and Project results. The report keeps final local acceptance pending until delivery-HEAD checks and completed, Done, and readback confirmation occur. Changed files: - "docs/superpowers/reports/2026-11-11-welcome-migration-presentation-verification.md" (+7/-5 lines). The file counts compare the staged tree with its first parent. Staged-Tree: 989df9b
Explicit original PR disposition before aggregate integrationIssue #234 now has independently accepted candidate managed/native evidence, final whole-branch review on Before the aggregate merge, explicitly retarget PR230 from This route follows the coordinator's retained conditional decision |
Integrated disposition verifiedGitHub reports this PR as actually merged after its explicit recorded retarget to main and the normal PR240 integration. Actual API merge SHA: Current main CI43526566733, CodeQL43526566754 and governance43526566734 pass. Raw logs confirm2684 managed+10 font tests,0 failures/skips, both secret scans and GUI/MSI/tool builds. New190 and separate real-close tail acceptance are recorded in issue234. The broader installed/functional/release boundaries remain separate. Final issue234 closure and actual Project Done readback are queued behind the shared heavy-resource release; no closed-unmerged or inferred Done claim is made. |
|
Final issue234 acceptance and Project readback are complete: six-section accepted record. Issue234 is closed as completed with7/7 criteria. This PR is actually merged, and its existing Project7 card is now independently verified Done/P2/Architecture/Low with lumenpearson/G2/canonical labels under grant287 and actual release288. Exactly four scoped Status writes, zero other field writes and zero added cards. All original source heads and remote branches remain preserved. The earlier pending procedural state is superseded by this actual final readback; broader G1/G3-G5/installed/release boundaries remain separate. |
Problem
WelcomeViewModel.Migration owns nine observable display values together with operating migration state. This makes notification order, callback reentry and error presentation difficult to review independently. This local G2 stage extracts only that display responsibility while preserving the existing private-set host facades, public signatures and synchronous notification behavior.
Changes
Verification
Product:
be8808356fd7846ffc9b8bf297b042aa72705fe3. Delivery HEAD:5c7a9459589b6d8c18a794d675c29ac0ed285e54(documentation only after the tested product). Windows x64, .NET SDK8.0.427.dotnet test CDPIUI.Tests/CDPIUI.Tests.csproj -c Release --no-restore:2672/2672,0failed/0skipped.8D46633D07827850E8ECCF69D99A1402B3502203F6419C9B8DE3A6A0DF0E3A65.Details: verification report.
Risk and recovery
Low: bounded in-memory presentation ownership. Default equality, raw null/list/double semantics, ordering, partial effects, exception propagation and callback reentry are explicitly characterized. Two Minor coverage limitations remain documented: the finite setter theory does not independently assert every first supplied value, and constructor coldness is source evidence because the native observer subscribes after construction.
Retain frozen parent b0f2c93 and all prior refs/artifacts. Use additive correction without destructive cleanup, force, rebase or foreign worktree changes. This draft does not establish loaded wizard/EN-RU/accessibility, operating migration, installed-product, G1, broad integration or release acceptance.
Related work
Refs #231. Parent architecture/integration: #14; native/integration and release gates #13/#15 remain separate. Stack base is frozen PR #230 at b0f2c93, branch dev/configmaker-status-presentation. No main merge or retarget is part of this stage.
Maintainer checks
type:label and at least onearea:label on this PR.LOCAL acceptance recorded in issue231 comment6808342201. Issue231 closed as completed, actual Project Done verified after fresh navigation under179, all6criteria checked. PR232 remains draft/In progress on frozen parent230; broad integration and release acceptance remain separate.