Skip to content

[V2-EFF-01.2–.6] Qualify efficiency telemetry, dashboard and selected receiver adoption #4640

Open
3 of 3 issues completed

Description

@EHotwagner

Owner: Programme/root (current Codex coordinator) owns whole-Outcome reconciliation and integration. Home/SystemAdmin is the user-selected application custodian and installation/access operator (#4640 (comment)); source owners retain existing PR/attempt provenance. Takeover: #4516 (comment).

Done when: Complete V2-EFF-01.2–.6: qualify facts and coverage through one real provider → selected receiver/store → projection → browser journey, including separately admitted interruption/Unknown, recovery and correction. Complete the plan’s later calibrated assessment/adoption and rollback obligations without inventing cost or savings.

Current deliverable: Child4707 is now CLOSED/COMPLETED with verified StatusDone and complete scoped provider-to-receiver/store-to-projection-to-real-browser acceptance. Its accepted actual receiver correction, canonical48 and12 browser assertions are reusable. Known producer spool/outcome observations predate09:10 and still do not establish that outage-time recovery/refusal assertion.

Next action: Root retains the accepted4707 receiver/browser journey. After the user-prioritized shared runner→bake→registration→first BAR path, select one complete genuine interruption/Unknown/recovery/correction and assessment/adoption/rollback journey with Home, exact source/inputs, separate original clocks and actual custody. No current operation or source worker is running for this remaining Outcome; do not create progress from the accepted48-row/12-browser result.

Blocked on: The named next prerequisite is the primary shared-native path (#4650/#4778/#1032), followed by Root/Home selection of the genuine remaining receiver journey and its actual input/custody closure. Broader .2–.6 acceptance remains absent. Source and current success cannot establish outage-time recovery, calibration, adoption or rollback; original failures/gaps remain. No new user decision is missing.

Acceptance evidence: Child completion4707#6396226736 and native CLOSED/COMPLETED09:58:41Z; scoped receiver/canonical/browser evidence4516#6395866955/#6396011677/#6396118047/#6396159841. Current child success does not establish missing producer outage observations or whole parent acceptance.

Rootscopedreceiver6395866955, canonical/r8selection6396011677, actualbrowserreturn6396118047 and independentacceptance6396159841. Currentr8 browser/retirement succeeded; exactproducer09:10gap is retained separately.

2026-10-25 continuation reconciles active4707 first. Native channel6394886185 and Root source/metadata selection retain exact scopes; previous durable receipt/store and supported-counter acceptance remain valid. No parent closure or completed browser inference.

Determining child4707 issue plus Home4516#6394193801/#6394204097/#6394272686/#6394350081; Root continuation message6394437989. Child Status Blocked was independently verified before this parent; full V2-EFF outcome remains open.

Boundary2026-10-23: source/runtime/receiving disposition #4516 (comment); conditional4816 selection #4816 (comment); current4818 source FS-GG/FS.GG.Templates#764; BAR repair FS-GG/FS.GG.Coordination#1057. Each supports only its owning scope.

Updated child #4707 at2026-10-21T11:32:44Z records scoped publication acceptance and the corrected application-custody prerequisite. Original publication39580298871/a1, read-only org observation39591087147/a1 and Host0.8 release419394647 are joined by genuine immutable manifest/public-journal bytes and independently verified package archives from both feeds. Org archive44273495 and signed NuGet archive97a1d4aa match their original public-journal rows and common producer payloadf0368085; original/new authenticated non-draft immutable release establishes promotion. The original five-of-eight report and403 remain historical facts, with the three missing dependencies resolved by new actual bytes. Scoped process retirement was independently checked. Full original Done when, prior accepted evidence, decomposition and all history are retained below. Owning plan and dashboard plan retain complete authority; parent and child remain open.

Historical complete parent body before scoped Host0.8 publication acceptance (preserved verbatim; inactive planning history):


Owner: Programme /root owns outcome reconciliation and the next delivery-owner decision. Existing .github dashboard, telemetry and receiver owners retain their surfaces; Programme /root is accountable for the integrated receiver window, with the existing telemetry application owner implementing and Home/SystemAdmin supplying host operations.

Done when: Complete V2-EFF-01.2–.6: qualify facts and coverage through one real provider → selected receiver/store → projection → browser journey, including separately admitted interruption/Unknown, recovery and correction. Complete the plan’s later calibrated assessment/adoption and rollback obligations without inventing cost or savings.

Current deliverable: Source #4679/PR4685 and #4707's Host successor source PR4782, original candidate39574162631/a1 and preflight39578047585/a1 retain their accepted scopes. Original publication39580298871/a1 succeeded, but independent org-package bytes remain Unknown after GET403; five independent effects verify and three retain their dependent Unknowns. Programme/root has now admitted the existing #4707 owner /root/sc2_prerequisite to the selected four-path hosted org-read source continuation, with original source start 2026-10-21T10:57:55.089751+00:00, deadline 2026-10-21T11:27:55.089751+00:00 and profile CPU4 / memory1GiB / original1800 seconds, isolated source-only work. This actual bounded child source work supports Outcome In progress; source review, CI and delivery remain outstanding. No hosted org observation, full independent publication acceptance, Home installation, genuine receipt or provider-to-browser acceptance follows from source dispatch.

Next action: The same #4707 owner implements the selected source proposal through one ordinary follow-up PR to closed PR4782, focused controls, independent exact-source review, unchanged required CI and protected merge/readback. Keep the existing release-successor-feed-readiness workflow, closed Host0.8 read branch, unchanged contents:read/packages:read and default coherent-set branch, one bounded org-package GET, unchanged verifier and bounded genuine evidence artifact. Programme/root separately admits any first-attempt hosted read only after source acceptance. Reuse original publication39580298871/a1; no rebuild, republish, candidate/publisher retry or journal reset is selected. Home's existing owners still supply authenticated bounded service/cutover, exact installed artifact/configuration/store provenance, current-data fence and backup/recovery. #4705 supplies the genuine durable canonical receipt for #4707's full sanitized projection/browser and privacy/coverage acceptance. Interruption/Unknown, recovery/correction, later calibrated assessment/adoption and rollback remain required.

Blocked on: No Home package-read operator blocks this independently useful selected source continuation. Full independent publication acceptance still requires genuine org-package bytes and the dependent reader assertions. The complete provider → receiver/store → projection → browser journey still requires compatible installed Host, authenticated receiver/store/cutover, trusted final-name HTTPS, #4705's genuine receipt and actual ingestion/browser/recovery/correction evidence at their existing owners. Later calibration and economic acceptance retain their own prerequisites. All original failures, operations, 0.6/journal12 Unknown, 0.7/journal13 scope and inherited439/46 holds remain; no parent completion or reservation release is implied.

Acceptance evidence: Programme/root admission and the existing owner’s acknowledgement at 2026-10-21T10:57:55.089751+00:00 under the retained original1800-second source window establish only the active source boundary. The selected four-path proposal is SHA256 e46a4c8975a052f38056e7b25d5520584fbaeafa71b18a7c547efa17f09e3988; the current [#4707 body](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/issues/4707) preserves its exact scope and remaining assertions. Prior accepted source, candidate, preflight and native publication evidence, complete two-child decomposition and all earlier limitations are retained verbatim below. Closed #4679 remains accepted; #4707 is the active bounded source child only. No actual hosted org-byte read, Home/provider/browser result or whole-parent acceptance is asserted. [Owning plan](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/blob/main/docs/roadmaps/process-efficiency-telemetry.md); [dashboard plan](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/blob/main/docs/roadmaps/utel-telemetry-dashboard.md).

Receiver input reconciliation: [verified current access/service metadata](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/issues/4516#issuecomment-6253495420), [completed stable address](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/issues/4516#issuecomment-6253487948), and [independent address disposition/next owner action](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/issues/4516#issuecomment-6253569367). Private topology, custody and operation receipts remain restricted.

Decomposition design and scoped remaining acceptance: https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/issues/4701; `docs/coordination/2026-10-19-board-clearing-lifecycle-design.md` (owning source plan; publication remains separate). Next bounded result: https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/issues/4707; native creation/link/enrollment and actual acceptance remain separate.


Historical current-field boundary before PROC/LEARN/UTEL priority reconciliation (preserved verbatim):

> Current deliverable: Bounded source delivery #4679 is accepted via https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/pull/4685, merged2026-10-19T05:58:45Z at af9cc28605b70fc6c35e544f1666d0711143f829. Independent final-head review PASS and full hosted qualification passed; tested/delivered tree843c317924ebf3d8e0d0f344557199583e957fcb is identical. Hosted run39203944049 executes118 telemetry tests,64 dashboard tests and6 Chromium tests, plus actual HTTP authority and reproducible packaging. Engine run39203944235 also passed. Initial source/fixture/metadata failures remain retained originals. This accepts source only and does not complete this parent outcome.
> 
> Decomposition under #4701: Next scoped Delivery: https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/issues/4707. It preserves the existing implementation owner and original PR/operation where applicable; it is not an implementation assignment by itself. Accepted evidence above retains only its recorded scope. Remaining full promise: Separately admitted interruption/Unknown, recovery and supported correction; bounded completion assessment, held-out calibration/disposition, later assessment adoption and rollback remain V2-EFF-01.2–.6 obligations. No economic claim without complete evidence.
> 
> Next action: Join the selected compatible coherent/Host publication and installed provenance to UTEL receipt delivery, then qualify the actual projection/browser path. Fresh-read the existing Home source/delivery disposition before repeating any access blocker. Next scoped Delivery: https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/issues/4707. It preserves the existing implementation owner and original PR/operation where applicable; it is not an implementation assignment by itself.
> 
> Blocked on: SOURCE #4679 can proceed independently of Home access. The complete real provider → selected Home receiver → projection → browser acceptance now has original owner enrollment, independently verified strict-pin client access and stable-address supply. It still needs verified current package provenance, trusted final-name HTTPS, compatible installed versions and its own ingestion/runtime/recovery/correction evidence. Home owns the execution/custody route; the telemetry application owner verifies ingestion and projections. Later calibration, billed cost and benefit claims retain separate evidence requirements.
> 
> Current determining clarification under #4701: Real authenticated receiver ingestion and compatible current package/cutover joins are still required. Native host authority is Home-owned; the browser owner cannot infer it from source tests. Publication and installed adoption remain separately admitted. All other existing conditions and original uncertain effects remain retained; this clarification grants no new authority or reservation release.



Historical active-source fields before accepted Host milestones and scoped blocking (preserved):

> Current deliverable: Accepted source #4679/PR4685 and its exact hosted evidence remain intact. Child #4707 now has active root-admitted independent Host successor source preparation owned by /root/sc2_prerequisite, original1800 seconds from2026-10-21T06:44:54Z under CPU4/memory2GiB source-only limits. The concrete gap is that published Host0.7 predates the accepted unassigned-usage browser feature. This active child supports In progress without completing any whole-parent acceptance.
>
> Next action: Continue the existing4707 owner through the admitted source scope, exact review and normal protected delivery; root separately selects meaningful hosted qualification, publication and installed Home adoption. Preserve the complete facts-and-coverage provider-to-browser, interruption/Unknown, recovery/correction, calibrated assessment/adoption and rollback obligations. No billed-cost or savings claim is admitted without its complete evidence.

> Acceptance evidence: Root source admission2026-10-21: existing4707 owner /root/sc2_prerequisite acknowledged original1800 seconds, CPU4/memory2GiB and isolated source-only scope on protectedf8b2088efcf03f96252dcdd92f8bda7b84983f24; successor proposal SHA2560349cb24549de092147d949ddd7688fb4bb19e0131addc3c01d354f107fa23af. No coordinate, package, host adoption or complete runtime acceptance is inferred. [owning plan](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/blob/main/docs/roadmaps/process-efficiency-telemetry.md); [dashboard plan](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/blob/main/docs/roadmaps/utel-telemetry-dashboard.md); [#4623](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/pull/4623) and [#3652](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/issues/3652). Presentation delivery does not complete the receiver or whole feature. [Unified v3 outcome index](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/blob/main/docs/roadmaps/2026-10-07-unified-development-roadmap-v3.md#2-open-work-and-owning-plans).


<details>
<summary>Historical current fields before the new root-admitted hosted org-read source continuation (preserved verbatim)</summary>

Current deliverable: Source #4679/PR4685 and #4707's Host successor source PR4782, original candidate39574162631/a1 and preflight39578047585/a1 are accepted at their respective scopes. Original native publication39580298871/a1 succeeded, with release/tag/assets/public NuGet and protected journal14 generation17 independently observed. Full independent publication acceptance remains incomplete: org-package GET403 leaves the maintained effect reader at five verified and three dependent Unknowns. No child product operation remains active: #4679 is closed source delivery; #4707 is Blocked after guarded readback2026-10-21T10:19:24Z. The retired06:44 source window is retained below as history. Home installation, genuine receipt and full provider-to-browser acceptance remain open.

Next action: Programme/root reconciles this Outcome to Blocked against the complete two-child readback; no whole-outcome closure follows. The existing #4707 owner's concrete read-package proposal is prepared and reviewed, awaiting the existing authorized environment/operator response. Preserve the original publication; no rebuild, republish, workflow retry, journal reset or automatic read retry is authorized. Home's existing installation/application owners supply the authenticated bounded service route, exact installed artifact/configuration/store and current-data fence/backup/recovery/cutover facts. #4705 then supplies the genuine durable canonical receipt, which #4707 reuses for actual sanitized projection/browser facts and truthful privacy/coverage. Full interruption/Unknown, recovery/correction, later calibrated assessment/adoption and rollback obligations remain. No additional source prerequisite or executable current child was established; independently useful later source work requires its own genuine Delivery selection.

Blocked on: The source preparation is accepted; the remaining installed journey retains its Home dependencies. The full real journey still requires4705 genuine durable receipt, compatible published/installed Host, authenticated receiver/store/cutover, trusted final-name HTTPS and actual browser/ingestion/recovery/correction evidence under the existing Home/application owners. Later calibration and economic acceptance retain their own prerequisites. All prior source/publication scope, ownership, original failures and Unknowns remain preserved.

Acceptance evidence: [PR4685](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/pull/4685) retains its accepted source scope. [Host source PR4782](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/pull/4782) merged as74cbd6f0b1b598d48556eb854c4ba6a3c3abda54, matching the independently reviewed tree;82 native checks passed and4 skipped. Root authenticated [candidate39574162631/a1](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/actions/runs/39574162631), artifact12334065598 with27PASS/0FAIL, and accepted [preflight39578047585/a1](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/actions/runs/39578047585) without publication effects. [Original publication39580298871/a1](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/actions/runs/39580298871) succeeded against that source. Independent readback verifies promoted [release419394647](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/releases/tag/telemetry-host/v0.8.0), tag/source/assets, normalized public NuGet payload and protected journal14 generation17 with all eight states marked verified. The maintained independent reader verifies tag/draft/nuget/package-asset/manifest-asset; github/publication-journal-asset/promote remain Unknown through the org-download403 dependency. Native promoted-release/journal evidence does not replace independent org bytes. [Child4707](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/issues/4707) retains the exact artifact/manifest/payload identities, accepted Atlas boundary and scoped operation evidence. Original local415/layout/parser failures, first-attempt identities,0.6/journal12 uncertainty,0.7/journal13 scope and439/46 holds remain unchanged. Complete native decomposition has exactly two children: closed #4679 and open/Blocked #4707; no actual Home/provider/browser or whole-parent completion is inferred. [Owning plan](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/blob/main/docs/roadmaps/process-efficiency-telemetry.md); [dashboard plan](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/blob/main/docs/roadmaps/utel-telemetry-dashboard.md).


</details>

Activity

  1. EHotwagner commented on Oct 22, 2026

    @EHotwagner
    ContributorAuthor

    Programme/root record 2026-10-22: by user decision, Home (SystemAdmin) is the telemetry application custodian and installation/access operator, replacing the unrecovered Main/application custodian; Programme/root accepts Home results only after independent subagent review. Request and roadmap: #4516 comment 6334674310 (marker utel-custodian-home-20261022); #4707 fields updated. Full promises, original effects and holds unchanged.

  2. EHotwagner commented on Oct 23, 2026

    @EHotwagner
    ContributorAuthor

    fdev record 2026-10-23: Claude Code native usage capture is source-complete; publication is next

    Claude Code usage is not yet measured at the receiver. Two source deliveries have merged, and the route rebind PR #4833 is waiting on fdev for the 0.113.0 publication.

    Merged:

    • #4835 (squash 5868f421): bounded retirement of finished passive sources and responses.
      • Before this, one passive association permanently stalled after 8 transcript files or 256 responses. Measured capture-only on real transcripts: two files filled the index in ten passes.
      • Every way of re-reading an already-counted response is now suppressed and reported as a gap: a hard link or rename, a continuity gap, a copy, or a rewrite of a closed file.
      • Independent critic ACCEPT at exact head 581d9ae2; required CI green.
      • Atlas lesson: github/passive-capture-finite-state-retirement.
    • #4834 (squash b4933bfa): independent Host 0.9.0 source.
      • Journal utel-host-rel-15, predecessor genuine 0.8.0 (74cbd6f0).
      • Admits claude-local-transcript/1, which Host 0.8.0 refuses. Store14 is unchanged, so Home can cut over without migration.
      • Re-pins the read-only org observer and guards it at PR time.
      • Critic ACCEPT at 9c6e98f1; required CI green.

    Ready, not merged:

    Remaining, in order. Each step needs its own admission:

    1. Coherent 0.113.0: merge Rebind the coherent release route to 0.113.0 over promoted 0.112.0 (Refs #4640) #4833, then candidate, publish=false preflight, publish=true, and readback, with the main and Authority-writer hold.
    2. Host 0.9.0 publication. It must not run in parallel with step 1, because both write Authority journals.
    3. Read-only host-090-org-artifact observer PR, then the registry reconcile.
    4. Home cutover to Host 0.9 through [cross-repo] V3-ENV-01: name the host provisioner and independent cleanup owner #4516.
    5. Side-by-side install of coord 0.113.0 on fdev, a separate passive association and credential enrolled by Home, then capture and drain triggers.

    Drain requirement: a drain sends at most one passive envelope per association, while one capture pass produces at most one batch of 24 responses. Drains must therefore run at least as often as capture batches. At 128 ready envelopes or 8 MiB, capture stops and keeps its cursors, so nothing is dropped.

    Atlas: the Host 0.9 capture is owed at its publication.

    — fdev

  3. EHotwagner commented on Oct 24, 2026

    @EHotwagner
    ContributorAuthor

    Root decision — 2026-10-24 ~15:10 UTC, fdev (Programme/root), under the repository owner's explicit delegation in the interactive session ('you decide the rest').

    Scope narrowing of unsupported counters. Counters the provider does not support (billed cost, other-host and unsupported usage counters) are reported permanently as Unknown and are no longer acceptance prerequisites. Whole-population coverage is accepted on supported counters with truthful Unknown reporting. No attribution, baseline or cost is invented. The rest of Done when is unchanged.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions