Repository navigation
docs: Guide document maintenance update - #165
loom-fleet-dispatch[bot] wants to merge 1 commit into
Conversation
Automated document maintenance by Guide triage agent. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <[email protected]>
|
Judge pass: still carries a fresh Stand-down passes against this claim: 1 of 3 before the bounded fallback force-reclaims it. This comment is edited in place on each pass rather than reposted (#5123, #6514). |
|
Code evaluation used the docs-only fast path: the complete paginated changed-file list contains only root-level WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md, and formal review/inline-thread reconciliation is clear. CI has not settled: Rust (macos-latest), Rust (ubuntu-24.04-arm), and Rust (ubuntu-latest) remain pending after the bounded foreground wait. Releasing the Judge claim without a verdict; the PR remains on loom:review-requested for a fresh pass once CI completes. |
|
Judge pass: still carries a fresh Stand-down passes against this claim: 8 of 3 before the bounded fallback force-reclaims it. This comment is edited in place on each pass rather than reposted (#5123, #6514). |
|
Reclaiming loom:reviewing claim: 8 consecutive stand-down passes have accumulated against claim 2026-10-07T16:45:03Z (age 36 minutes, above the 30-minute threshold) with no claimant activity — bounded fallback, LOOM_MAX_STANDDOWN_STREAK=3. |
|
Judge verification completed for e4fc519: paginated files API returned only WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md; gh pr checks 165 returned seven passing checks; mergeStateStatus=CLEAN; check-review-feedback.sh returned CLEAR (zero reviews, zero inline comments). Local tests were skipped under the docs-only fast path. Approval was not posted: post-verdict.sh refused with exit 5 because the installed loom-daemon does not recognize forge wait-checks. The mandatory CI approval gate requires loom-daemon >= 0.19.707. Releasing loom:reviewing and leaving loom:review-requested for re-evaluation after the daemon is updated. |
|
Judge: docs-only fast-path eligibility verified using the paginated files API (WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md). gh pr checks 165 reports all seven checks passing; check-review-feedback.sh reports CLEAR with zero formal reviews and zero inline comments. Approval could not be posted: post-verdict.sh exited 5 because installed loom-daemon 0.19.623 lacks forge wait-checks, which the approval gate requires from 0.19.707 onward. No verdict was posted. Releasing loom:reviewing and leaving loom:review-requested for re-evaluation with a compatible daemon. |
|
Judge: docs-only fast path applies (only WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md changed), |
|
Judge verification: the paginated files API returned only WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md (docs-only fast path); gh pr checks 165 returned seven passes; mergeStateStatus was CLEAN; check-review-feedback.sh returned CLEAR with zero formal reviews and inline comments. Approval was not posted: post-verdict.sh exited 5 because the installed loom-daemon does not recognize forge wait-checks (the gate names minimum version 0.19.707). Releasing loom:reviewing and retaining loom:review-requested. Update the installed daemon and re-run Judge; no approval label was applied. |
|
Docs-only review completed for head e4fc519. The paginated files API confirms that the entire change is confined to WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md, qualifying for the Judge docs-only fast path. Local build/tests were skipped under that path. Formal reviews and inline threads are clear, merge state is CLEAN, and all seven checks reported by Approval remains blocked by CI verification permissions. The passing reported checks do not establish whether additional required contexts are missing. The integration needs access to read the applicable branch-protection/required-check configuration before Loom can approve. Releasing loom:reviewing and leaving loom:review-requested for a fresh Judge pass once access is restored. No approval verdict has been issued. Final live recheck found loom:reviewing already removed and loom:review-requested still present. Standing down without changing labels. |
|
Judge: docs-only fast path review is complete and the diff is fine (WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md only). All 7 CI checks pass on e4fc519 and the merge state is CLEAN. I could not post the approval. |
|
Judge evaluation passed the docs-only fast-path checks: the full paginated file list contains only WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md; all seven checks passed in gh pr checks; merge state is CLEAN; formal reviews and inline threads are clear. Approval could not be recorded because post-verdict.sh requires the exact-head CI gate, but the installed loom-daemon does not support forge wait-checks. The gate refused before posting a verdict. Releasing loom:reviewing and leaving loom:review-requested for re-evaluation after the daemon is updated. |
|
Judge evaluation: the paginated changed-file list is exactly WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md, qualifying for the docs-only fast path. GitHub reports all seven checks passing and CLEAN merge state; the formal-review gate returned CLEAR. Approval could not be posted: post-verdict.sh refused because the installed loom-daemon lacks forge wait-checks (requires >= 0.19.707). No verdict posted. Releasing my claim and leaving loom:review-requested for re-evaluation after the daemon is updated. |
|
Judge: docs-only fast-path eligibility verified via the paginated files API: WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md only. gh pr checks 165 reports all seven checks passing; check-review-feedback.sh reports CLEAR with zero formal reviews and inline comments. Approval remains unissued: the installed loom-daemon does not recognize forge wait-checks, required by post-verdict.sh for its exact-head CI gate. Leaving loom:review-requested in place and releasing the review claim; re-evaluate after the daemon is updated. |
|
Judge review could not record approval: paginated files API returned only WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md (docs-only fast path), gh pr checks returned seven passes, merge state was CLEAN, and check-review-feedback.sh returned CLEAR. However post-verdict.sh exited 5 because the installed loom-daemon does not recognize forge wait-checks; the mandatory exact-head CI gate refused approval. Releasing my claim and leaving loom:review-requested. Update the installed Loom daemon to support forge wait-checks (script requires >= 0.19.707), then re-run Judge. |
|
Docs-only review eligibility confirmed: the paginated
Approval remains unsettled: |
|
Judge: docs-only fast-path eligibility verified using the paginated files API (WORK_LOG.md, WORK_PLAN.md). gh pr checks reported seven passing checks, merge state CLEAN, and check-review-feedback.sh reported CLEAR. Approval was not posted: post-verdict.sh exited 5 because installed loom-daemon does not support forge wait-checks, so its mandatory exact-head CI gate refused approval. Releasing the review claim and leaving loom:review-requested. Update the installed loom-daemon (script names resync-installed.sh / roll loom-daemon), then re-run Judge. |
|
Judge docs-only evaluation: the paginated changed-file list contains only WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md; all seven CI checks pass via gh pr checks, merge state is CLEAN, and formal review reconciliation is CLEAR. Approval could not be posted: the installed loom-daemon lacks forge wait-checks, so post-verdict.sh refused approval (exit 5). Leaving loom:review-requested and releasing my claim; update the daemon before re-running Judge. |
|
Docs-only fast-path checks passed for head e4fc519: the paginated files API returned only WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md; check-review-feedback.sh reported CLEAR (0 formal reviews, 0 inline comments); gh pr checks showed all 7 visible checks passing; mergeStateStatus was CLEAN. Local tests were skipped under the docs-only fast path. Approval remains unverified: loom-daemon forge wait-checks 165 --timeout 20 returned LOOM-CHECKS-TIMEOUT (required-contexts-unknown), with: required-context lookup for main failed: classic branch-protection lookup failed: gh api graphql failed: gh: Resource not accessible by integration. The integration needs access to read branch protection/required contexts before the approval gate can establish success. Releasing loom:reviewing and retaining loom:review-requested for a later verified verdict. |
|
Docs-only fast-path eligibility verified through the paginated files API: WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md only. check-review-feedback.sh returned CLEAR (0 formal reviews, 0 inline comments). gh pr checks 165 reports all seven listed checks passing; the live merge state is CLEAN at e4fc519. Approval remains unsettled: loom-daemon forge wait-checks 165 --timeout 20 returned LOOM-CHECKS-TIMEOUT (required-contexts-unknown) because the branch-protection lookup failed with Resource not accessible by integration. Required-context verification could not be completed. Releasing loom:reviewing and leaving loom:review-requested for a later pass. |
|
Judge evaluation reached the docs-only fast path: the paginated files API returned exactly WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md; gh pr checks reported seven passing checks; check-review-feedback.sh reported CLEAR. Approval was not posted: post-verdict.sh exited 5 because the installed loom-daemon rejects forge wait-checks as an unrecognized subcommand. This is a local tooling blocker. Leaving loom:review-requested and releasing the claim; re-evaluate after updating loom-daemon as directed by post-verdict.sh. |
|
Judge: docs-only fast-path eligibility verified via
Releasing the review claim and leaving loom:review-requested in place. The credential needs access to the required-check/branch-protection configuration before the approval gate can settle this head. |
|
Judge docs-only evaluation: paginated pulls/165/files returned exactly WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md, qualifying for the docs-only fast path. gh pr checks 165 reported all seven checks passing; mergeStateStatus was CLEAN; check-review-feedback.sh reported CLEAR (0 formal reviews and 0 inline comments). No local tests were run under the docs-only fast path. Approval remains blocked by tooling: installed loom-daemon 0.19.624 does not implement forge wait-checks, while post-verdict.sh requires >=0.19.707 and fails closed without that reader. Releasing loom:reviewing and retaining loom:review-requested so approval can be retried with a compatible daemon. This is a tooling blocker, not a requested change to this PR. |
|
Docs-only fast-path eligibility verified from the complete paginated files API: WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md only. Formal review and inline feedback gate is CLEAR; merge state is CLEAN; all seven checks reported by gh pr checks passed at head e4fc519. Approval remains unverified: loom-daemon forge wait-checks returned LOOM-CHECKS-TIMEOUT (required-contexts-unknown), with: required-context lookup for main failed: classic branch-protection lookup failed: gh api graphql failed: gh: Resource not accessible by integration. This is a credential permission blocker, not a code or failing-CI finding. Releasing the review claim and leaving loom:review-requested for a Judge with access to the required-context settings. |
|
Docs-only review is eligible: the paginated files API returned exactly WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md. check-review-feedback.sh reported CLEAR (0 formal reviews, 0 inline comments). gh pr checks reported all seven visible checks passing, and the merge state is CLEAN. TDD: absent; advisory only for this documentation update. Approval remains unverified: loom-daemon forge wait-checks 165 --timeout 20 returned LOOM-CHECKS-TIMEOUT (required-contexts-unknown), with: "required-context lookup for main failed: classic branch-protection lookup failed: gh api graphql failed: gh: Resource not accessible by integration". The reader credential needs access to branch-protection metadata before the approval gate can verify required contexts. Releasing loom:reviewing and retaining loom:review-requested for a later review; no approval verdict is posted. |
|
Reclaiming stale loom:reviewing claim (idle 651m > 30m with no claimant activity) — continuing the docs-only review. |
|
Judge review could not publish approval: paginated files API returned only WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md (docs-only fast-path eligible); gh pr checks 165 returned seven passing checks; merge state was CLEAN; check-review-feedback.sh returned CLEAR. post-verdict.sh refused approval (exit 5) because installed loom-daemon 0.19.624 lacks forge wait-checks, required since 0.19.707. No verdict was posted. Releasing my claim and leaving loom:review-requested for re-evaluation after the daemon is updated. |
|
Judge evaluation: docs-only fast-path eligibility verified through the complete paginated changed-file API: only WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md changed. Formal reviews and inline threads are clear; all seven checks visible through gh pr checks pass, and merge state is CLEAN at e4fc519. Approval remains inconclusive: loom-daemon forge wait-checks --timeout 20 returned LOOM-CHECKS-TIMEOUT (required-contexts-unknown), reporting that the required-context lookup was denied with Resource not accessible by integration. Releasing loom:reviewing and retaining loom:review-requested for a later pass with access to branch-protection requirements. No local tests were run under the docs-only fast path. |
|
Docs-only fast-path evaluation: the paginated pulls/165/files API returned exactly WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md. No local code checks apply to this diff shape. check-review-feedback.sh reported CLEAR (0 formal reviews, 0 inline comments). gh pr checks 165 reported all 7 visible checks passing; mergeStateStatus is CLEAN at e4fc519. Approval remains unverified: loom-daemon forge wait-checks 165 --timeout 20 returned LOOM-CHECKS-TIMEOUT (required-contexts-unknown), with: required-context lookup for main failed: classic branch-protection lookup failed: gh api graphql failed: gh: Resource not accessible by integration. Releasing loom:reviewing and leaving loom:review-requested in place. A subsequent Judge must verify required contexts using a credential with access before approval. |
|
Reclaiming stale loom:reviewing claim: 696 minutes idle with no claimant activity, exceeding the 30-minute threshold. |
|
Judge docs-only evaluation: the paginated files API returned only WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md; gh pr checks returned seven passing checks; merge state is CLEAN; formal/inline feedback gate returned CLEAR. Approval could not be posted: post-verdict.sh exited 5 because installed loom-daemon 0.19.624 lacks forge wait-checks (approval gate requires >=0.19.707). No verdict was posted. Releasing the review claim and leaving loom:review-requested for reevaluation after the daemon is updated. |
|
Judge: docs-only fast-path review is clean (files: WORK_LOG.md, WORK_PLAN.md; review-feedback gate CLEAR; all 7 CI checks pass in |
|
Judge: document-only fast-path eligibility verified via paginated files API (WORK_LOG.md, WORK_PLAN.md). gh pr checks returned seven passing checks, and review-feedback gate returned CLEAR. Approval was refused by post-verdict.sh (exit 5): installed loom-daemon does not support forge wait-checks. No verdict posted; leaving loom:review-requested and releasing my claim for re-evaluation after the daemon is updated. |
|
Docs-only fast-path review: the paginated pulls/165/files API returned only WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md. check-review-feedback.sh reported CLEAR (zero formal reviews and zero inline comments). gh pr checks 165 reported all seven visible checks passing; mergeStateStatus is CLEAN at e4fc519. However, loom-daemon forge wait-checks 165 --timeout 20 returned LOOM-CHECKS-TIMEOUT (required-contexts-unknown): required-context lookup failed with Resource not accessible by integration. Approval is withheld because the CI gate could not verify required contexts. Releasing loom:reviewing and leaving loom:review-requested for a later pass. |
|
Judge: docs-only fast-path eligibility verified; gh pr checks reports seven passing checks and review-feedback gate is CLEAR. Approval could not be posted: post-verdict.sh refuses because the installed loom-daemon lacks forge wait-checks, so its mandatory exact-head CI gate cannot run. No verdict was posted. Releasing the review claim and leaving loom:review-requested for re-evaluation after loom-daemon is updated. |
|
Docs-only fast-path evaluation: the paginated files API returned exactly WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md. check-review-feedback.sh returned CLEAR (0 formal reviews, 0 inline comments). gh pr checks reported all seven visible checks passing. Approval remains unverified: loom-daemon forge wait-checks 165 --timeout 20 returned LOOM-CHECKS-TIMEOUT at e4fc519 (required-contexts-unknown), with: "required-context lookup for main failed: classic branch-protection lookup failed: gh api graphql failed: gh: Resource not accessible by integration". Releasing loom:reviewing and leaving loom:review-requested for a later pass with access to the required-context configuration. No approval or rejection verdict issued. |
|
Docs-only fast-path verification completed: the paginated files API returned only WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md; gh pr checks reported seven passing checks; merge state was CLEAN; formal-review reconciliation returned CLEAR. Approval could not be posted: post-verdict.sh refused because the installed loom-daemon lacks forge wait-checks, which its exact-head CI gate requires (minimum 0.19.707). No verdict was posted. Releasing loom:reviewing and leaving loom:review-requested for re-evaluation after the daemon is updated. |
|
Judge: docs-only fast-path eligibility confirmed using the paginated PR files API: WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md only. check-review-feedback.sh reports CLEAR (zero formal reviews and inline comments). gh pr checks reports seven passing checks, and mergeStateStatus is CLEAN for head e4fc519. Approval remains unverified: loom-daemon forge wait-checks 165 --timeout 20 returned LOOM-CHECKS-TIMEOUT (required-contexts-unknown), with: required-context lookup for main failed: classic branch-protection lookup failed: gh api graphql failed: gh: Resource not accessible by integration. The credential needs access to read branch-protection requirements. Releasing loom:reviewing and leaving loom:review-requested for a later pass; no approval verdict issued. |
|
Judge evaluation completed on head e4fc519: docs-only fast-path review is clear, GitHub reports all seven checks passing, merge state is CLEAN, and review-feedback reconciliation is clear. Approval was not posted because the mandatory exact-head CI gate could not read CI: the installed loom-daemon lacks 'forge wait-checks'. Releasing loom:reviewing and leaving loom:review-requested for re-evaluation after the installed daemon is resynced; no verdict label was written. |
|
Judge: documentation fast-path eligibility verified through the paginated files API (WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md only). gh pr checks reports seven passing checks, merge state is CLEAN, and check-review-feedback.sh reports CLEAR with zero reviews and inline comments. Approval remains unissued: post-verdict.sh exited 5 because the installed loom-daemon does not support forge wait-checks, so its required exact-head CI gate cannot run. Update the installed daemon and re-run Judge. Releasing loom:reviewing and retaining loom:review-requested. |
|
Judge: docs-only fast-path eligibility verified through the paginated files API: only WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md changed. check-review-feedback.sh reports CLEAR (0 formal reviews, 0 inline comments). gh pr checks 165 reports all seven visible checks passing, and mergeStateStatus is CLEAN. Approval remains unverified: loom-daemon forge wait-checks 165 --timeout 20 returned LOOM-CHECKS-TIMEOUT (required-contexts-unknown), with "required-context lookup for main failed: classic branch-protection lookup failed: gh api graphql failed: gh: Resource not accessible by integration". This is an access refusal, so waiting will not resolve it; the operator needs to restore access to required-check configuration. Releasing loom:reviewing and retaining loom:review-requested for a later verified verdict. |
|
Judge: verified docs-only fast-path eligibility via the paginated files API (WORK_LOG.md and WORK_PLAN.md). gh pr checks 165 reported all seven checks passing; merge state was CLEAN; check-review-feedback.sh reported CLEAR with zero formal reviews and zero inline comments. Approval was not posted: post-verdict.sh exited 5 because the installed loom-daemon does not support forge wait-checks, so its mandatory exact-head CI gate could not run. Releasing loom:reviewing and leaving loom:review-requested. Update/resync loom-daemon, then rerun Judge. |
Summary
Automated document maintenance by the Guide triage agent.
Automated by Guide role - document maintenance phase
🤖 Generated with Claude Code