Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
62 lines (54 loc) · 3.17 KB

python-vs-arch.md

File metadata and controls

62 lines (54 loc) · 3.17 KB

Python package against arch

Generated by python/benchmarks/bench_vs_arch.py. Every number below comes from the one machine listed here; the ratios compare runs on that machine only and say nothing about another one.

The matched-work rows fit the same simulated series (GARCH(1,1) with Student-t(8) innovations, default_rng(7)) with the same specs: constant mean, sGARCH(p,q), gjrGARCH(1,1), eGARCH(1,1) and EWMA (lambda estimated, arch's EWMAVariance(None)), each with normal, Student-t or GED innovations, plus sGARCH(1,1) with skewed Student-t innovations (sstd against arch's skewt, the same family with another parameterization). volengine runs with Context(threads=1) and var_init="backcast", the arch convention; arch runs with rescale=False and fit(disp="off"), one fit after the other. Each timing is the total wall time of the fits it covers.

  • Machine: AMD Ryzen 7 5700X 8-Core Processor, 8 cores, 16 hardware threads, 32 GiB RAM, Windows-10-10.0.19045-SP0
  • Versions: volengine 1.0.0, arch 8.0.0, numpy 2.5.4, Python 3.14.7
  • Date: 2026-11-17
  • Work: 20 series of 5000 observations, 19 specs, 380 fits per library; median wall time of 5 repetitions.
Run Wall time (s) Fits per second Relative to arch on this machine
arch, sequential (matched work) 16.80 22.6 1.00x
volengine, threads=1 (matched work) 3.14 120.9 5.35x
volengine, threads=0 (all cores; not matched work) 0.59 642.1 28.39x
Model (matched work) Fits arch (s) volengine, threads=1 (s) Relative to arch on this machine
sGARCH 200 9.60 1.87 5.14x
gjrGARCH 60 4.05 0.48 8.45x
eGARCH 60 2.61 0.67 3.88x
EWMA 60 0.53 0.12 4.31x
Spec Worst relative loglik difference over the series
sGARCH(1,1) norm 5.1e-11
sGARCH(1,1) std 4.8e-11
sGARCH(1,1) ged 4.3e-11
sGARCH(2,1) norm 1.6e-09
sGARCH(2,1) std 5.2e-09
sGARCH(2,1) ged 3.5e-09
sGARCH(1,2) norm 7.5e-09
sGARCH(1,2) std 3.6e-08
sGARCH(1,2) ged 1.5e-08
sGARCH(1,1) sstd 4.2e-11
gjrGARCH(1,1) norm 5.1e-11
gjrGARCH(1,1) std 4.9e-11
gjrGARCH(1,1) ged 3.6e-11
eGARCH(1,1) norm 1.0e-09
eGARCH(1,1) std 4.4e-10
eGARCH(1,1) ged 5.2e-11
EWMA(1,1) norm 5.1e-11
EWMA(1,1) std 3.3e-11
EWMA(1,1) ged 2.3e-11

Notes:

  • The optimizers differ (L-BFGS in VolEngine, SLSQP in arch), so the times include different numbers of iterations. The second table shows that both reach the same optimum: the largest relative difference of the log-likelihood over the 20 series is below 1e-4 for every spec (the script fails otherwise).
  • The threads=0 row is not matched work: arch does not parallelize a fit, so that row measures the batch parallelism of VolEngine, not the algorithms. Fits are bit-identical for any thread count.
  • The run was not isolated: a normal desktop session, no pinned cores and no fixed frequency.
  • Reproduce with VOLENGINE_LIB=<path to the library> python python/benchmarks/bench_vs_arch.py --out docs/performance/python-vs-arch.md in the python/.venv environment.